newlogo.gif (2148 bytes) Review of A Crocus Selection
 

“Another brother dies

Another day flies

Another mother haunts

Her home with her own cries

Another man falls

To another chant and call

From another racist neighbour

Behind another thin wall...”

(from: ‘City Life’ by Lemn Sissay in  A Crocus Selection)

Events  

Writers & Readers

Groups 

Discussion

West Midlands Writing 

What to Read?

World Writing

Resources

News & Comment

Other Sites

Home


A Review

This is one of the most beautiful books of poetry I've ever come across. It is a pleasure to look at and to touch. Every poetry book should feel as good as this. We might say the quality of the words is more important than the quality of the print and paper, but they help too.

Especially if you can't see. I can. I do it without thinking all the time I'm awake. So, probably, do you. This is a dual text - English print and braille side by side. I can't read the braille, but as I touch it now, I think of the US presidential election farago and hoo-hah about pregnant pimples and wonder "Aren't we all blind at least some of the time." How many braille books of poetry do you know?

It's the first I've come across. You might be thinking "Poetry Book for the Blind. Full of hoary old chestnuts." Cobblers. This is a selection from the best northwest poetry in the last ten years. Again, how often do blind people have the chance to read contemporary poetry, or do they have to make do with hoary old chestnuts?

There are only thirteen poems, but such a beautiful book at £2.50, it's good value for money. You may not find you like them all. I didn't, but then can you find any anthology where you like them all? Two favourites were Eileen Holroyd's Ms Hughes (click here) and Sophie Hannah's Something You Should Know (click here) Both are different in form but similar in character: Ms Hughes is written in the vernacular of a homophobic little old lady; Something You Should Know is the formal style Betjeman could embrace, if not all its sentiments. All the poems share this particular quality: to question, to get beneath the accepted, and then explain. As Matthew Sweeney puts it in his Introduction:-

Robert Frost defined poetry as a "A fresh look and a fresh listen', and this definition is hard to improve on. He also said 'an idea has to be a little new to be at all true, and if you say a thing three times, it ceases to be so' which is the same thing put a slightly different way. And he's saying is so simple, yet so crucial that it never ceases to shock me to find so much poetry written that makes no attempt to follow Frost's advice. None of that poetry is gathered here.

True.

If I were a librarian, I'd buy this book. In fact I'd buy at least two copies and cut one of them up and mount the poems on the wall somewhere prominent with the print and braille versions side by side. With thirteen in all, there are just enough for one a month - to keep their display as well as the poems fresh. Does your library have braille guides to the lifts, to the catalogues and shelves of books on tape....

It won't happen. I'm not a librarian. Also libraries don't work quite like that. At £2.50 a copy, there should be more than enough money in their book funds to buy a copy for every library in the land. This would make it a runaway poetry best seller. Let me explain: Rhyme & Reason: developing contemporary poetry, published The Arts Council of England on 5th October, last National Poetry Day makes grim reading. For a start at £15 and 156 pages long there isn't a line of poetry in it. The statistics on page 6 mean annual contemporary poetry sales in the UK are around £0.5m - the wages of a below average Premier League soccer player, or a half-decent pop video. Clearly the libraries and the rest of us aren't buying poetry. If you are a librarian, what will you buy - one copy of Rhyme & Reason, or six of A Crocus Selection, or none?

Well, it's getting near Christmas. Why not bulk buy a bunch of Crocii for pressies (around half the books in this country are bought as pressies for Christmas) Shame about the £2.50 price on the back - A Crocus Selection is worth far more than that.

Go to your local bookshop or library with this information:-

A Crocus Selection by Suzanne Batty et al, edited by Matthew Sweeney, published by Crocus Books & The National Library for the Blind ISBN 0-946745-27-7, £.2.50, Spiral bound 80 pages, dual format text and braille

A Crocus Selection can be ordered direct from The National Library for the Blind, Far Cromwell Road, Bredbury, Stockport SK6 2SG. Cheques/postal order for £2.50 should be made payable to The National Library for the Blind

Send reviews and comments to Cathy Bolton, Crocus Books, Cheetwood House, 21 Newton Street, Manchest M1 1FZ tel: 0161 236 2773 e-mail cathy@commonword.org.uk


click here for review of "Like I'm running in a hurdle race"
  reflections on caring in Sandwell, in the words of carers themselves

click here how to foster reader development in care homes

click Discussion to hear about Literature and Disabilities


And if you want the details for
Rhyme & Reason: developing contemporary poetry, £15, 156 pages ISBN 0-7287-0810-8 published by The Arts Council of England, 14 Great Peter Street, London SW1P 3NQ tel: 020 7333 0100 minicom 020 7973 6561 fax 0207973 6590 large print or braille contact the Information Department on 020 7973 6453
www.artscouncil.org.uk e-mail enquiries@artscouncil.org.uk

David Fine Lit-Net Co-ordinator


 

Ms Hughes

 

Matron, you know I hate complaining
but it's that Ms Hughes again, refuses
to eat her evening meal, never touches
meat but this is fish and I think she should
be told about the bathroom door, she insists
on locking it, serve her right if she slips
and breaks her hip, not that I wish
it on her, God forbid, but a fall'd bring
her down a peg, still what can you expect
from someone who shared a flat with another
woman, what's more I hear she was arrested
once for taking part in one of them there
protests, ban the bomb or some such crackpot
march, it's not fair that the likes
of her just please themselves while others

have to stick to our routine, still
what can you expect from the kind
of woman who's never had a man.

 Eileen Holroyd

 


 

Something You Should Know

There's something you should know about this town.
Details would take too long, but here's the gist:
White envelopes are much preferred to brown.

Fawn-coloured ones are greeted with a frown.
Don't call me over-cautious. I insist,
There's something you should know about this town.

 Although there is the odd, disruptive clown
Who'll send a beige one when he's really pissed,
White envelopes are much preferred to brown.

For deviants, the only way is down.
It does no good to be an anarchist.
There's something you should know about this town,

(For even you, a man of high renown,
Could be the target of an angry fist) -
White envelopes are much preferred to brown.

They'll lock you up. You'll wear a starched, white gown -
Hospital style. What's more, you won't be missed.
There's something you should know about this town:
White envelopes are much preferred to brown.

Sophie Hannah

 

 



 click here to return to the review


 Menu Bar

Last modified: December 01, 2000